August 22, 1915
According to Charlton’s Baseball Chronology, this is the only time it has ever happened. It came in the second inning of game one of a double header.
First, Chick Gandil and Merit Acosta drew consecutive walks. Buff Williams sacrificed the runners to second and third with a bunt. George McBride then plated Gandil with a sacrifice fly, but the Tigers caught Acosta off second base with the throw from the outfield. One run, three outs, no at bats.